I ended the wear test, the result has been a bit surprising for me.
Generally my tops with a spiked carbide tip, after about 5 - 10 hours of spinning, start to wobble (nutation) spontaneously, because of weared contact points.
Here an example, the top at the right is wobbling because of weared contact points:
https://youtu.be/kXDKc8vOz3M?t=102This is why I started using often HHS spiked tips, which are quite less prone to this problem.
The wobbling top in the video weighs 160 grams.
My two latest tops weigh both 119 grams. I wanted to see if the reduced weight would help to decrease wear of the contact points using the carbide tip.
The result is that after 50 hours of spinning the top was still spinning smoothly, without any wobbling, still perfectly vertical at medium and high speed. This is better than I hoped.
I observed the base (made of tungsten carbide) at the microscope and saw this:
This is a mm 0.06 hole (deep about mm 0.02); it is a littler hole than that of the top in the video, but I started wondering if the reduced weight of the top could be the only cause of the absence of any spontaneous nutation wobbling.
I cleaned the base from the oil and tried to spin the top without oil: this usually facilitates the spontaneous nutation in a top spinning in a holed base.
But still no wobbling at all. The top spinned very well with no problems.
I tried to force a nutation kicking the stem of the top with a finger:
the top started nutating but the nutation disappeared rapidly, it lasted less than half a minute, then the top spinned smoothly again, without any wobbling.
When I do this with a top with deeply recessed tip, the nutation lasts for longer time, (two, three minutes or even more), even if the contact points are in perfect conditions.
I have come to think that the cause is probably related to the height of the center of mass:
if CM is at the contact point, or very near to it, nutation in the flywheel happens in the same way as in a flying nutating object, there isn't any strong opposition to nutation.
But if the tip is external, at some distance from the CM, then the tip has to slip on the spinning surface, for the top to nutate about the CM. Or, the tip doesn't slip, but in this case the CM has to move in circular motion, during a nutation, but the CM tends to be steady, (inertia), so I think that in this situation there is a natural resistance against nutation, and this is why this top refuses to wobble spontaneously.
I made efforts in the past to solve this problem, looking for harder and more wear resistant materials for the contact points. I made various tests, spent time and money.. without finding a definitive solution.
Now a solution has come, accidentally...