I tried using the back of my guitar as soundboard, but my tops are too silent. Spiked tips are quite silent.
My fine tips are pretty quiet, too.
If you're interested in a top that makes sound with its tip (as opposed to whistling or hissing), you might try a "textured" or ball tip. Many of my tops are built around through-going splined central axles like the dark gray ones below. Longer axles have both of the terminations shown, one at each end.
In forming my tips, I usually cover the lower end of the axle with something smooth like the black 10 mm ball below. Ball tips like this make interesting sounds on suitable soundboards -- e.g., the lid of a large empty plastic bin. When the bare axle is the tip (right), the sounds are both louder and more complex -- in part, because the way the top travels across the soundboard also changes.
Details on these fun little underhand tops
here.