The oldest toys according to ta0 (I was not there but I can guess):
1- Food (berries, insects, nuts, etc)
2- A stone
3- A stick
4- Food still alive (moved to carnivore diet)
5- Sticks in the shape of weapons
6- Beads, paints, teeth and other decorating things
7- Water toys (flat stones, wood, leaves)
Thousands of years later:
8- Dolls
.
.
.
1000- yo-yo
Spintops depends what type. Some nuts can spin well, so I subscribe to the idea [1] that the first tops were finger food and thus the first toys
Now, throw tops probably around number 500
[1] Prof. Robert Greenler,
"Why does a spinning top stop?"